Fat Sal's
Italian Specialties
Fat Sal's
Italian Specialties

Fat Sal's Italian Specialties

Fat Sal's Italian SpecialtiesFat Sal's Italian SpecialtiesFat Sal's Italian Specialties

SAVOR FRESH DELI ITEMS & IMPORTED ITALIAN GOODS

View Our Menu

(732)-281-8581

About Fat Sal's

Authentic Italian Experience

At Fat Sal's Italian Specialties & Salumeria, we bring the flavors of Italy to Bayville, NJ. We have a large variety of Italian imported products & our deli offers a variety of freshly made sandwiches, ensuring every bite is a taste of authenticity.

Menu

SIGNATURE SUBS

FULL SUB $26 - HALF SUB $14

Forgotten boro

Deluxe ham, store-made mozzarella, fried eggplant & sun-dried peppers

morris park

Chicken cutlet, store-made mozzarella, & broccoli rabe

napoletano

Mortadella, provolone, & tomato

new yorker

Pastrami, melted Swiss cheese, coleslaw, & mustard

romeo & juliette

Hot & sweet sopressata, provolone, roasted peppers, & balsamic glaze

sicilian

Chicken cutlet, deluxe ham, & store-made mozarella

sweet caroline

Maple honey turkey, Lacey swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato & honey mustard

famous Bronx godfather

Prosciutto, sweet sopressata, capocollo, mortadella, store-made mozzarella, mixed greens, sun-dried peppers, & balsamic glaze

american

Deluxe ham, ovengold turkey, roast beef, Genoa salami, American & Swiss cheeses, lettuce & tomato

italian

Prosciutto, sopressata, capocollo, mortadella, provolone, roasted peppers, oil & vinegar

jersey shore

Roast beef, lettuce, tomato, onions, oil & vinegar

calabrese

Prosciutto, hot sopressata, store-made mozzarella, & fried hot peppers

chicken fat sal's

Chicken cutlet, store-made mozzarella, & roasted peppers

eggplant fat sal's

Fried eggplant, store-made mozzarella, & roasted peppers

the yankee

Prosciutto, store-made mozzarella, fried eggplant & roasted peppers

mulberry street

Prosciutto, hot sopressata, hot capocollo, store-made mozzarella, roasted peppers, balsamic glaze, oil & vinegar

Sophia loren

Deluxe roast beef, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, oil & vinegar

the kid

Deluxe ham, ovengold turkey, bologna & muenster cheese

the pig

Store-cooked porchetta, store-made mozzarella, & cherry peppers

Italian tuna

Tuna, baby arugula, roasted peppers, red onions, olives, & lemon juice

chicken parm

eggplant parm

sausage & peppers


PREMIUM MEATS & CHEESES

Priced per lb.

DELUXE HAM

12.99

MAPLE HONEY HAM

12.99

CAPPY HAM

12.99

bologna

8.99

deluxe roast beef

14.99

store cooked roast beef

15.99

corned beef

15.99

pastrami

15.99

ovengold turkey

13.99

cracked pepper mill turkey

14.99

MAPLE HONEY turkey

14.99

mortadella with pistachios

12.99

prosciutto di parma

32.99

prosciutto

19.99

sopressata (hot or sweet)

22.99

capocollo (hot or sweet)

22.99

American cheese (yellow or white)

9.99

swiss cheese

10.99

baby swiss cheese

10.99

lacey swiss cheese

10.99

muenster cheese

10.99

provolone cheese

10.99

Vermont cheddar

10.99

jalapeno pepper jack

10.99

CATERING

HALF OR FULL

Home style lasagna

HALF 60.00 FULL 120.00

Whole milk, ricotta, mozzarella, pure pork, Italian sausages, all beef chopped meat, locatelli cheese, homemade macaroni & sauces

home style baked ziti

HALF 50.00 FULL 95.00

Oven baked macaroni in a delicious sauce, with ricotta, mozzarella, & imported cheese

home style manicotti

HALF 45.00 FULL 90.00

Homemade dough filled with full cream mozzarella & ricotta, garnished with imported cheese & plenty of homemade sauce

baked ravioli

HALF 50.00 FULL 100.00

Homemade ravioli prepared in our delicious meat sauce

PEnne vodka

HALF 45.00 FULL 85.00

Prepared in our creamy homemade sauce w/ prosciutto & onions

cavatelli & broccoli

HALF 45.00 FULL 85.00

Fresh homemade cavatelli, prepared w/ garlic sauce & broccoli

Cavatelli & broccoli rabe

HALF 50.00 FULL 95.00

Fresh homemade cavatelli, prepared w/ garlic sauce & broccoli rabe (available with sausage)

Stuffed shells

HALF 45.00 FULL 95.00

Extra large shells, prepared w/ ricotta, mozzarella, & topped with our own delicious sauce

eggplant parmigiana

HALF 45.00 FULL 95.00

Farm fresh eggplant sliced & prepared in our homemade sauce, topped w/ mozzarella & garnished w/ grated cheese

eggplant rollettes

HALF 50.00 FULL 100.00

Rolled eggplant, filled w/ creamy ricotta & mozzarella filling, & topped w/ delicious homemade sauces

Italian meatballs

HALF 55.00 FULL 110.00

All beef chopped meat prepared w/ the finest ingredients & cooked in our own delicious homemade Italian sauce

Swedish meatballs w/ brown gravy

HALF 45.00 FULL 90.00

Chicken parmigiana

HALF 50.00 FULL 100.00

Filet of chicken breast breaded & cooked to a golden brown, then smothered w/ plenty of whole milk mozzarella, topped w/ imported romano cheese

chicken scarpariello

HALF 55.00 FULL 100.00

Off the bone - sausage, cherry peppers

chicken balsamic

HALF 45.00 FULL 95.00

W/ vinegar peppers & mushrooms in balsamic

chicken w/ vinegar peppers

HALF 45.00 FULL 95.00

Breaded chicken sauteed w/ vinegar peppers, garlic, and oil

chicken francese

HALF 50.00 FULL 100.00

Chicken cutlet prepared w/ delicious homemade lemon sauce

chicken marsala

HALF 50.00 FULL 100.00

Chicken cutlet prepared in a brown mushroom sauce w/ a touch of marsala wine

barbequed chicken (boneless)

HALF 50.00 FULL 100.00

Chicken cooked to a golden brown, topped w/ our delicious honey based BBQ sauce

chicken fingers

HALF 50.00 FULL 95.00

Tasty chicken fingers, cooked to a golden brown

Veal and peppers

HALF 70.00 FULL 140.00

Tender and delicious fancy veal, diced
& cooked in a zesty sauce & smothered in peppers

sausage and peppers

HALF 50.00 FULL 100.00

All pork Italian sausages, garnished w/ pepper and cooked in olive oil to a golden brown

pork pizzaiola

HALF 55.00 FULL 100.00

Tender slices of filet of beef, cooked in a delicious tomato & wine sauce

miniature brocalettes

HALF 60.00 FULL 110.00

Filet of pork or beef sliced, seasoned & topped w/ brown sauce

baby back ribs

HALF 60.00 FULL 110.00

Juicy, meaty & succulent style spare ribs

RICE balls (mini- need 2 days notice)

HALF 40.00 FULL 80.00

potato croquettes (need 2 days notice)

HALF 40.00 FULL 70.00

BRoccoli rabe

HALF 45.00 FULL 80.00

Sauteed w/ garlic & oil

broccoli florets

HALF 35.00 FULL 60.00

Sauteed w/ garlic & oil

House salad

HALF 40.00 FULL 75.00

Romaine, olives, tomatoes, cucumbers


Italian antipasto

SMALL $55.00 - MEDIUM $85.00 - LARGE $125.00

COLD antipasto platters

prices may vary w/ substitutions & add-ons

Prosciutto - sweet dry sausage sopressata - imported provolone - marinated mushrooms - mixed olives - artichokes - roasted peppers - bocconcini


CHeese platters

PLEASE INQUIRE FOR PRICING

ENJOY a delicious assortment of your favorite domestic and imported cheese

Diced and served on decorated platters w/ fancy frilled toothpicks.


CONQUERING HEROES

3-6 FEET - $25 per foot

OVERSTUFFED heroes

American style

fried or grilled chicken cutlet

w/ roasted peppers & mozzarella

fried eggplant

mozzarella & roasted peppers

Italian combo

provolone, prosciutto, sweet sopressata, capicola, mortadella, roasted peppers, oil & vinegar

POTATO salad, macaroni salad, & Cole slaw

5.00 per lb.

sun-dried peppers, broccoli rabe

3.00 extra per foot

balsamic glaze

2.00 extra per foot

Contact Us

Better yet, see us in person!

791 Atlantic City Blvd, Bayville, NJ 08721, USA

(732)-281-8581 info@fatsalsitalianspecialties.com

Hours

Open today

09:00 am – 07:00 pm

Questions, Comments?

Attach Files
Attachments (0)

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Cancel

Social

Savor the flavors: PHOTO gallery

    01/15

    Copyright © 2025 Fat Sal's Italian Specialties - All Rights Reserved.

    Powered by

    This website uses cookies.

    We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

    Accept